© 2026 KALW 91.7 FM Bay Area
91.7 FM Bay Area. Celebrating 85 Years of KALW Public Media.
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Judge rules in favor of San Jose license plate reading cameras

A singular Flock camera stands in front of blue sky and greenery
Tony Webster
/
Wikimedia
About 500 automatic license plate readers have been installed in San Jose.

A judge has dismissed a lawsuit challenging San Jose's network of license plate reader cameras, dealing a legal setback to opponents of a technology that has divided the city's residents over fears of dragnet surveillance.

The Santa Clara County Judge rejected arguments that the city's use of automated license plate reader data violates the California Constitution's guarantee of privacy rights and prohibition on unreasonable searches.

San Jose Spotlight reports the ruling follows the lead of an earlier decision from a California Appellate Court that found drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy when traveling through public streets.

San Jose maintains a network of about 500 automatic license plate readers.

The court ruling rejected plaintiffs' arguments that the sheer quantity of cameras in San Jose makes the city's network a far more invasive law enforcement tool.

Opposition to license plate reading cameras has increased in many Bay Area municipalities, specifically amid concerns over sharing data with federal law enforcement agencies, such as ICE.

Sunni M. Khalid is a veteran of more than 40 years in journalism, having worked in print, radio, television, and web journalism.