Toronto Removed Basketball Hoops From Parks Every Day. Then A Tweet Called It Out
The Toronto Raptors won the NBA Championship earlier this month, and the team's thrilling run has boosted the city's excitement about basketball to a new level.
But you wouldn't know it, watching a video posted this week of a Toronto city worker removing a basketball hoop from an outdoor court at one of the city's parks.
Absolutely sickening display @cityoftoronto let the kids play!!! pic.twitter.com/myjsOvZEc0— Mitch Robson (@_mitchrobson) June 26, 2019
As a child dribbles a ball on a gorgeous sunny day, the worker takes down the rims, leaving nothing but backboard.
A young man assures the camera that even without the hoops, "I can have just as much fun out here." He goes in for the layup ... but there's nowhere to put the ball. It ricochets off the backboard.
The hoops' removal wasn't a one-off, captured by chance: It was policy. For years, city workers have removed the hoops each evening from some Toronto parks, in response to noise complaints from neighbors.
City spokesperson Brad Ross told Toronto's Star newspaper that crews "would make their way to various parkettes ... and remove the nets and replace them the next day to mitigate noise complaints."
Then came Mitch Robson's tweet on Wednesday, which made the Canadian city look, well, somewhat hostile to joy and exercise. As of Friday afternoon, the video had been viewed more than 1.5 million times.
Canada's basketball governing body soon weighed in, posting a doctored photo showing the Raptors playing on a basket without a hoop. "No rim. No history. Everyone deserves the chance to play. Keep the nets up," it urged.
No rim. No history.— Canada Basketball (@CanBball) June 27, 2019
Everyone deserves the chance to play. Keep the nets up. #WeAreTeamCanada pic.twitter.com/IvHq8BBtk2
The city responded quickly.
Within hours, Toronto Mayor John Tory announced his disapproval of the practice.
"The City should be putting basketball nets up not pulling them down," he tweeted. "I've delivered that message to our parks staff tonight — they agree. We should absolutely be encouraging kids to play in our city."
The City should be putting basketball nets up not pulling them down. I’ve delivered that message to our parks staff tonight - they agree. We should absolutely be encouraging kids to play in our city. https://t.co/Sk1UQn5UVC— John Tory (@JohnTory) June 27, 2019
The city released a statement the next morning discontinuing the practice, explaining that it had stemmed from an attempt "to balance the rights of everyone to enjoy Toronto's parks – and play basketball – with the rights of residents adjacent to those parks when it comes to noise."
Hoops had been removed only from parks close to homes, the city said, but it now recognized that taking them down at 6 p.m. "is not reasonable."
Effective immediately, the city said it would suspend hoop removal "so residents can continue to enjoy a game of basketball into the evening."
Below is our statement on the removal of basketball hoops in some parks. This practice has been suspended effective immediately. pic.twitter.com/pdt2zDWiNW— City of Toronto (@cityoftoronto) June 27, 2019
The Toronto District School Board also announced that it would leave up its basketball nets outside school hours — though it said the move would be a "6-month pilot project to better understand any potential issues."
Not everyone was impressed. "Where was this 20 years ago when I was in school," one person tweeted. "Took them down every year in scarborough. All it took was an nba championship and social media. SMH."
Robson, who posted the initial video of the rims being removed, posted a photo the next day that suggested the city was following through on its vow.
BREAKING: The rim is back up and looking majestic at Phin Park, according to my sources. Let's hope it stays up past 6:00pm! @cityoftoronto #RimsUp pic.twitter.com/GdSBhHRSel— Mitch Robson (@_mitchrobson) June 27, 2019
"The rim is back up and looking majestic at Phin Park, according to my sources," he wrote. "Let's hope it stays up past 6:00pm!"
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.