© 2021 KALW
KALW Public Media / 91.7 FM Bay Area
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
Crosscurrents logo 2021

Responding to rising numbers of high school-aged newcomers, an Oakland middle school opens it doors

Hannah Kingsley-Ma
A classroom at Bret Harte Middle School, which recently started a 9th grade class to accomodate high-school aged students who have been in the country for three years or less

Like a lot of middle schools, Bret Harte’s hallways carry with them the faint scent of Axe Body Spray and the sounds of kids shuffling to class. The school sits in the middle of Oakland, nestled below the big Mormon Temple. Outside, backpacks dangle from a tall, chain-link fence encircling a busy baseball diamond.

It’s hard not to notice, too, that plastered everywhere are posters reading “Refugees are Welcome Here” and “We All Belong Here and Defend Each Other.” Katherine Wolfe, the director of Bret Harte’s newcomer program, says those posters communicate an important message: “Let the outside be the outside, but here at Bret Harte know you are loved, you are accepted, and we want you to learn.”



Credit Hannah Kingsley-Ma
A hallway in Bret Harte Middle School. The school's newcomer program takes in recently arrived students from all over the world, many who are asylum seekers, refugees, and unaccompanied minors.

The newcomer program at Bret Harte has historically served middle school-aged students who have been in the country for three years or fewer. The school has students from all over the world. Wander around its halls, and you can hear a math class being taught in both English and Spanish, and the Arabic-speaking librarian calling up monolingual parents to make sure they have access to important information

This isn’t a dynamic unique to Bret Harte. Several middle schools throughout Oakland Unified School District have newcomer programs, and the population of newcomers in the district has dramatically increased in the past three years, especially when it comes to high schoolers. Four years ago, the number of high school-aged newcomers in OUSD was close to 600. In 2017, it’s more than doubled.

Most of these students are asylees, refugees, or unaccompanied minors. They’re fleeing countries like El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala, where systemic gang violence and extreme poverty are causing war-like conditions, driving kids to make the perilous journey across the border by themselves in search of refuge. Once here, many go through the complicated and backlogged court system to try and win asylum or special juvenile immigration status. This process has gotten even more difficult under the immigration policies enforced by the Trump administration. The Oakland Unified School District helps connect students to free legal counsel. It’s one of the many ways in which schools serving newcomer populations provide wrap-around needs for their students.

Credit Courtesy of Tom Hughes, from the Oakland Unified School District
Over the past four years, the numbers of high-school aged newcomers has steadily risen. Above, projections of the number of students expected this year and next.

Opening its doors

Bret Harte Middle School saw that the number of high school-aged newcomers was growing, and that the four high school newcomer programs in the district were reaching capacity.  So they made a big change to their newcomer program, creating a ninth-grade class to take in high school-aged students.

The school made a good candidate for this expansion in part because they had the physical space to accommodate an expected 125 new students. They also already had the infrastructure in place. They have experienced newcomer teachers, plus a wellness center that provides health and counseling services to students and their families —  a crucial element in educating kids who might have experienced horrific violence, interrupted schooling, or sexual trauma in their past. Plus, the opportunity to grow the program created a lot of excitement in the school community.

“We feel like it is an imperative thing for us to do and we have a mentality of just ‘Oh we need that? Ok, let's make that happen,’” Katherine Wolfe tells me. “These are children, first and foremost, even 16-year-olds and 17-year olds. Children deserve our mercy, and these are kids who are coming from hard transitions from one country and another and they are bringing great hope and great dedication with them.”

Martín is one of those students (for safety reasons, we’re not using his real name). He’s from El Salvador, has a sweet sideways smile and crumples paper nervously in his hand when he talks to me. He tells me when he first got here, he was surprised -- in the best way -- by how respected and welcomed he felt, both by his teachers and by his peers, who are from all over the world. He’s been picking up Guatemalan slang from his classmates who speak an indigenous Mayan language, a little Arabic too from his peers from countries like Yemen.

Martín likes school, particularly math and science class, but back home it was hard for him to attend. “Where I lived it was very dangerous,” he told me. Lots of people were afraid to leave the house, and the only safe place was church. That’s because when you reach a certain age, gangs begin to forcibly recruit young men and threaten them if they don’t.

Katherine Wolfe sees the very real danger many of her students face back in their home countries as an integral part of the moral imperative of serving them here. “There are students who would for sure be required to join a gang, or killed, if they choose not to,” she tells me. “There are students who would be sent to countries where rape or sexual assault or violence would be a part of their daily life, and that kind of fate is not suited for any human. And if we have the power in our hands to choose that fate for that student? Then we most certainly have a responsibility to help them avoid that.”


Getting to school

Once Bret Harte opened its doors to high schoolers, they began to steadily enroll. “Starting in January, we took on about a hundred students in a month,” Wolfe tells me. Teachers found many of their students were having a hard time getting to school. They tended to live in Fruitvale, or in deep East Oakland. There are other high schools with newcomer programs in those neighborhoods -- schools like Castlemont High and Fremont High -- but those programs were largely at capacity. There’s no school bus system in the district, so Bret Harte can be a trek for a lot of the school’s new students.

“Because the fact that they [other high school programs] are full they are coming to us, by two, three different buses sometimes just to get to school in the morning,” says Brian Tang. He’s the community schools manager at Bret Harte. Like a lot of teachers here, he grew up in Oakland and knows its streets like the back of his hand. He says there’s a lot of intangible knowledge that goes into getting to and from school safely that the newcomers just don’t have.

“It's super difficult. They are navigating through neighborhoods [where there are] traditional gang wars, and now they are knee deep in it,” he says. Students new to the country don’t know the unspoken rules of the street, like, “‘I can't wear blue on this block, or ‘I can't wear red on this block. I'm trekking through them because I have to trek through them to get to school.’”


Credit Hannah Kingsely-Ma
Hannah Kingsely-Ma
A section of the school's family resource center, which is open to the students and their families.

A young man named Said, originally from Afghanistan, tells me he wakes up at 6 am and takes two buses to get to Bret Harte. He said he was placed there because there were other Afghani students who spoke Dari,  and those guys  helped him navigate the buses when he first got here.They still all ride together. “We get another boy like us,” he tells me smiling. “And his cousin like us, we come together.”

Newcomers make easy targets, and one of his friends has been jumped before. So they help look out for each other. Said remembers what it was like when he first arrived in this country. “I didn't know nothing,” he says. “I didn't have no friends, I was so quiet and I didn't know what to say to teachers or students. I couldn't even say ‘Can you guys help me?’ It was so scary.”



The struggle to balance school and work 

Navigating the outside world to get to school can be tough, but what educators struggle with most is the fact that so many newcomer students have to work.  

One student -- whose name we’re not using -- described her newcomer experience in a letter written in Spanish. She wrote that she left her whole family behind in Guatemala to make her American dream a reality. She sends money to her family back home and pays rent. She writes that at Bret Harte she has wonderful teachers and good friends, but she can only go to school a couple days out of the week because she has to work. No one else supports her economically. Being in school only part time means that it’s harder for her to learn English, and it’s going to take a lot longer for her to graduate.

This is a problem a lot of newcomers face, and the school district knows it. Starting next year, it’s going to try a new alternative high school program specifically designed for kids who have to work, with more flexible hours to accommodate job schedules. Katherine Wolfe says she’s glad the district is scaling up its solutions.

“There's not much that we can do as individual school sites to help,” she tells me. “Mostly we continue to message to students that their earning potential is significantly increased when they finish school, and try to help them emotionally if they are tired or if they are really balancing a tough schedule between school and work.”


As much as the school is trying to meet newcomers’ needs, there have been some setbacks. The district is currently experiencing major budget cuts, so Bret Harte had to let go of a part-time staff member, a fluent Spanish speaker who helped enroll students when they first arrived. The principal, Dr. Bianca D'Allesandro, also told me the school was considering extending the ninth grade class into a full fledged high school program, but that because of financial restraints, that plan is on hold.

It’s also just really hard to predict how many newcomer students are going to enroll each fall. In the past, the OUSD has gotten it wrong.

Regardless, educators like Wolfe say they’re prepared for whatever comes next.

“People want their children to do well,” Wolfe says. “They want their children to have a better life than they had, and so I still think we still see many people coming from war-torn countries because they know there's a chance they can give that to their kids. And as long as they’re willing to do that, we are willing to help.”

In her letter, the teenager who left her whole family in Guatemala and is helping support them and herself writes, “I can’t promise that I will be an excellent student at Bret Harte, but I promise to learn as much as I can. I want to keep learning, keep fighting, to move forward with my goals, my dreams.”



Hannah Kingsley-Ma is a reporter and producer living in San Francisco.